127 Meeting Pl Place, City of Williamsburg
(757) 912-4440
Real Estate Company
The City of Williamsburg wraps itself around preserved historic ground, and the housing sits right up against it, on streets that run out from that core and out toward an arts venue and a golf course on the edges of town. That is the shape of the place: a compact city where the homes for sale are spread across those pockets rather than gathered into one district. What comes up for sale ranges across the usual spread of styles and price points you would expect in a city this size, and the stock is not uniform from one street to the next. David Tortolini Realty Group works this market closely and can tell you which parts of it are producing listings right now.
Stay ahead with real-time updates — no searching required.
Start with the fact that supply here lands in the balanced range, which is simply the classification the ratio of listings to recent sales pace falls into. Nothing in that figure tells you anything about a particular house, so treat it as background and judge listings one at a time. On closings that have already happened, sellers have been getting at or above what they asked, so build your expectations from what homes actually closed at rather than from the number on the listing sheet. If you are shopping between $500,000 and $1 million, that band accounts for more of what is currently listed than of what has been selling, which means more standing inventory to work through in your range. Use it: see several, compare them properly, and give yourself the time that comparison takes.
The typical house here was built in 1997, with most falling between 1983 and 2006. At that age, the first round of big replacements has usually either been done or is coming due, so ask which ones and when: the roof, the furnace, the windows, the water heater. A house with paperwork on all four is a different purchase from one where nobody can tell you. Three bedrooms is the most common layout sold, at around $389,000, and the single largest group of closed sales landed between $250,000 and $500,000. Looking at what is listed right now, roughly a third is detached houses, roughly a third is townhomes, and about a fifth is condos. The historic core, including the Governor's Palace grounds, is part of what shapes the older end of this stock. Buy well here and you get a house with its systems already proven.
Listing agents type the school fields themselves, so treat them as what the listing says and confirm the current assignment for any specific address with the school district directly. On the elementary line, more than half of listings name Matthew Whaley Elementary, about a quarter name Laurel Lane Elementary / Fmr. Rawls Byrd, and a small share name Clara Byrd Baker Elementary. Most name Berkeley Middle, with small shares naming James Blair Middle and Lois S Hornsby Middle School. At the high school level, most listings name Lafayette, about one in ten name Warhill, and a small share name Bruton. None of these school fields shows a measurable difference in price. The same goes for architecture: about a quarter of homes are townhouses, with Transitional and Colonial each around one in ten, and no price difference tied to style.
A few community names come up often enough to be worth knowing. Quarterpath accounts for about a fifth of listings, Indian Springs about one in ten, and Quarterpath At Tutters Po, Westgate At Williamsburg and Barclay Square each a small share. Together those names cover about half of what is listed, which means a search built on community names misses most of this market. The filters that actually work here are property class, price band and frontage. Set those first, then use the names above as a way to narrow further if one of them turns out to suit you. Searching the other way around leaves a lot of listings out of view entirely.
Two things on this page are easy to misjudge: how close sales here have been running to the asking price, and what the age and condition of a roof means on a house in this climate. David Tortolini Realty Group tracks both, along with how architectural review works for exteriors inside the historic district and how proximity to William & Mary factors into a specific address. If you want, we can walk you through a short list of listings in your price band and tell you, house by house, what questions each one raises before you write an offer.
Some listings may be duplicated in the search results due to the co-mingling of listings from more than one multiple listing service. Should there be different listing information between the duplicated listings; user is advised to verify the accuracy of the listing information before making any financial decisions.
Get instant property value now!
Get instant property value now!