First Colony Homes for Sale
First Colony is a James City County neighborhood where roughly a fifth of the listings look out at water, a view from the back of the house rather than frontage you can tie a boat to. The rest sit back from it, and the stock runs to detached houses on their own lots, so the yard, the roof and the driveway are yours to keep up. What changes most from one listing to the next here is the outlook and the lot, and that is worth sorting early in a search. David Tortolini Realty Group works this area closely and can tell you which listings have the water view and which only sit near it.
Be the First to Know About New First Colony Homes
Stay ahead with real-time updates — no searching required.
Explore Other James City County Communities
First Colony Real Estate Map Search
Search by Bedrooms
First Colony at a Glance
- County
- James City County County
- ZIP codes in these listings
- 23185
- Data current as of
- October 2026
What is for sale in First Colony
Nearly every one of the homes for sale here is a house. That makes your search straightforward: you are comparing lots, square footage and the age of the systems, not weighing a house against a condo or a townhouse down the street. Set your filters to detached and you will see close to the whole market. If an attached listing does come up, treat it as the exception and look hard at what comes with it.
What to verify before you commit
- HOA dues, reserves, and amenity maintenance obligations.
- Community development authority or special tax district assessments.
- Flood zone designation and flood insurance requirement.
- Age-restricted or deed restriction rules for the community.
Working with David Tortolini Realty Group
The details that trip buyers up in First Colony are rarely the ones on the listing sheet. Association dues and what they are actually obliged to maintain, any special district assessment attached to the address, flood zone designation and whether insurance is required: these vary by property and they change what the house costs you every year. David Tortolini Realty Group knows where those answers live and how to get them before you write an offer. Send over a listing you are curious about and we will pull the association and flood details on that specific address so you know the full monthly number.
No current listings, please check back later.