The Settlement at Powhatan Creek Real Estate

The Settlement at Powhatan Creek Homes for Sale

The Settlement at Powhatan Creek is built around open protected ground, with Powhatan Creek Park and Blueway right here among the homes. What that means for a buyer is simple enough: a good share of what you tour backs onto or sits near preserved land rather than more rooftops. The housing itself runs new, and townhouses make up much of what is listed at any given time, alongside detached houses. David Tortolini Realty Group works this corner of James City County and knows how the pockets here differ from one another. Below is what the past year of sales actually says about price, pace and the kind of house your money buys.

< Search all Homes for Sale in James City County, VA

Be the First to Know About New The Settlement at Powhatan Creek Homes

Stay ahead with real-time updates — no searching required.

See Homes Before Everyone Else

The Settlement at Powhatan Creek Real Estate Map Search

The Settlement at Powhatan Creek at a Glance

County
James City County County
ZIP codes in these listings
23188
Typical asking price
$379,990 (median of 13 active listings)
Typical sold price
$420,000 (median of 29 sales, past 12 months)
Typical home
1,628 sq ft (n=13) · 3 bed / 2.1 bath (medians, n=13 listed now)
Months of supply
5.4 (balanced)
Sold-to-list
100% of asking (median per home sale, n=29)
Data current as of
October 2026

The Settlement at Powhatan Creek market right now

Months of supply here lands in the balanced range. That figure is a ratio of what is listed against the pace homes have been selling, so read it as a description of the stock on hand and nothing more. On sales that have already closed, sellers got at or above what they were asking. Again, that is a record of completed deals, not a rule about the listing in front of you. The one thing it should change is how you read an asking price: treat it as a real number worth studying rather than an opening figure. As for what you will be looking at, most of the homes for sale here are townhouses, so build your search with that in mind.

What your money buys in The Settlement at Powhatan Creek

The typical house here was built in 2025. That is new enough that builder cover may still be running, so ask what workmanship or structural warranty is left on a given house and whether it carries over to you. It also means the roof, the furnace and the windows are at the start of their lives rather than the end, and the maintenance calendar you inherit is a long way off. Three bedrooms is the layout that sells most often here, at around $418,000. Greensprings Interpretive Trail is in the area as well, which is worth knowing if you want your search weighted toward the preserved edges of the neighborhood. A house of this vintage asks very little of you in the first years of owning it.

Worth confirming before you write an offer

  • Whether the property has HOA covenants and mandatory assessments.
  • Proximity to Resource Protection Area or Chesapeake Bay buffer restrictions.
  • Flood zone designation given proximity to Powhatan Creek.
  • County real estate tax rate and any special service district fees.
  • Whether termite or moisture inspections are customary given regional wood-frame construction.

Working with David Tortolini Realty Group here

Two things on this page trip buyers up most often: how closely sales track the asking price, and the association terms and creek-adjacent restrictions that vary house to house in The Settlement at Powhatan Creek. David Tortolini Realty Group handles both routinely, reads the covenant and assessment paperwork on a specific address before you write anything, and knows how to pull the flood and buffer designations that apply to a given lot. If you want, we can set up alerts filtered to the layout and price band you are actually shopping, then walk the first few with you.

Newest Homes for Sale in The Settlement at Powhatan Creek, James City County, VA

3825 S Orchard, James City Co Greater Route 5
$659,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3.1 Baths ⋅ 10660690 MLS
Elegance, thoughtful custom upgrades, and beautiful wooded privacy distinguish this lovely home in The Settlement at Powhatan Creek. Offering three bedrooms on the first floor and a versatile finished lower level, this home combines gracious living with exceptional functionality. The beautiful kitchen features a vaulted ceiling, stunning quartzite countertops, a spacious island, customized cabinetry, a large pantry, and a smooth-top electric range added in 2022. The generous breakfast area is highlighted by a gorgeous window with an arched, custom plantation shutter that beautifully complements the warm honey-toned cabinetry. The kitchen opens to the inviting great room with hardwood floors, while the formal living and dining rooms feature exquisite moldings and beautiful hardwood flooring. The spacious first-floor primary suite offers a beautifully updated bath with granite countertops, a soaking tub, and a generous separate shower with decorative marble inlay. Two additional first-floor bedrooms share a full hall bath. The finished lower level provides exceptional flexibility with a spacious recreation room, full bathroom, and an additional room currently used as an exercise room but easily suited as a fourth bedroom. Two generous walk-in storage areas include one thoughtfully outfitted as a workshop. Outdoor living is equally inviting, with a deck and lower-level patio overlooking a peaceful, wooded backdrop. Enjoy the exceptional lifestyle offered by The Settlement at Powhatan Creek, a sought-after 55+ community featuring indoor and outdoor pools, a clubhouse, and wonderful recreational amenities. Ideally located with convenient access to all that Williamsburg has to offer!

3825 S Orchard, James City Co Greater Route 5

Start Your Search

Some listings may be duplicated in the search results due to the co-mingling of listings from more than one multiple listing service. Should there be different listing information between the duplicated listings; user is advised to verify the accuracy of the listing information before making any financial decisions.

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!