Governors Land Real Estate

Governors Land Homes for Sale

Governors Land is built around a golf course, with Two Rivers Country Club set among the homes here, so fairway edges and the greens shape how a good many of these lots sit. Roughly a third of the listings look out at water, which is a view from the house rather than frontage you own, and that distinction is worth holding onto as you compare one property against another. There is a preserve and park ground here as well. Homes for sale run from houses on golf-side lots to those with that water outlook, and David Tortolini Realty Group works this area closely enough to tell one kind of setting from another on paper.

< Search all Homes for Sale in James City County, VA

Be the First to Know About New Governors Land Homes

Stay ahead with real-time updates — no searching required.

See Homes Before Everyone Else

Governors Land Real Estate Map Search

Governors Land at a Glance

County
James City County County
ZIP codes in these listings
23185
Typical asking price
$949,000 (median of 22 homes, excluding 1 land and other non-dwelling listings)
Typical sold price
$1,069,000 (median of 28 home sales, excluding 1 land and other non-dwelling sales, past 12 months)
Typical home
4,220 sq ft (n=22) · 4.5 bed / 3.2 bath (medians, n=22)
Months of supply
9.4 (leaning to buyers, homes only)
Sold-to-list
100% of asking (median per home sale, n=28)
Data current as of
October 2026

How the Governors Land market is moving

Start with the supply picture: measured as standing listings against the pace homes have been selling, it leans toward buyers. That is a ratio and nothing more, so treat it as context when you are lining up what to tour rather than a signal about any one house. On the sales that have already closed, sellers got what they asked or a little more. Know that going in so the numbers you see in the record do not surprise you. If you are shopping between $1 million and $2 million, that band makes up more of what has sold than of what is listed, so be ready to move through those properties as you find them and keep your financing squared away. Nearly everything for sale here is a house, which simplifies the search.

What your money buys in Governors Land

The most common layout sold here is a four-bedroom, and those have been running around $1,075,000. The typical house dates to 1998, which tells you what to ask about: whether the roof has been replaced and when, the age of the air handler, and whether the water heater is original. At that age some of that work is already done and paid for by someone else, and the seller should be able to tell you which. The windows and furnace are worth the same question. The Virginia Capital Trail is in Governors Land, so if being near it matters to you, factor that into which part of the community you spend your touring time in. For the money, you are getting a substantial house on its own lot, with the grounds and the systems yours to run.

What to verify before you commit

  • HOA dues, assessments, and reserve funding.
  • Golf club membership requirements and fees.
  • Gated community access and security fees.
  • Transfer fees or resale capital contribution to the association.
  • Rental and leasing restrictions within the community.

Working with David Tortolini Realty Group

Two things on this page are easy to misjudge from the outside: how close sales here land to the asking price, and the stack of association, club and gate-related costs that come with a house in Governors Land. David Tortolini Realty Group tracks both and can lay out, property by property, what a given listing actually carries. If you want, we can set up alerts for four-bedroom homes for sale in the range you are working in and walk the numbers with you before you write anything.

Newest Homes for Sale in Governors Land, James City County, VA

1924 N Fowlers Close, James City Co Greater Route 5
$2,750,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4.3 Baths ⋅ 10660686 MLS
This extraordinary residence nestled on a cul-de-sac with 2 acres of beautifully landscaped grounds offers the combination of refined luxury,exceptional craftsmanship, and inviting spaces. Step inside to walnut flooring, custom millwork & designer lighting. The great room is anchored by a custom floating fireplace with walnut hearth and pre-cast mantel. The chef's kitchen is appointed with Miele and Subzero appliances and Wood-Mode cabinetry. Curated details include floating shelves, marble backsplash and a metal-clad stone hood. A large center island features a moveable walnut Parsons counter. A wet bar with icemaker, refrigerator drawers sets the stage for the metal waterfall bar crafted by a Ballas artisan. The 1st floor primary suite offers a retreat with fireplace, sitting area, & 2 spacious walk-in closets. The primary bathroom features marble floors and walls, floating vanities, and a Victoria + Albert freestanding tub. The 2nd floor includes 3 bedrooms, 2 ensuite & 1 full bath. A rear staircase connects to a rec room, full wet bar, home theater, and half bath. Outdoor living unfolds across a raised terrace of travertine extending around a resort inspired pool with stone wall and waterfall. The large screened in porch with soaring wood ceiling, kitchen space with grill, beverage refrigerator & adjacent half pool bath completes the outdoor extension of the living spaces. A study, work-out room, walk-in storage & 3 car garage add the finishing touches to this home.

1924 N Fowlers Close, James City Co Greater Route 5

1415 Katherine Shaye Lane, James City Co Greater Route 5
$799,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2.1 Baths ⋅ 10660273 MLS
Just minutes from Two Rivers Country Club! Tucked away in a beautiful enclave of just eight homes, this highly sought-after villa in Governor’s Land offers a wonderful combination of privacy, charm, and an exceptional location. Natural light fills the dramatic two-story great room, where soaring windows and a gas fireplace create a warm and inviting gathering space. The great room opens to a charming sunroom with built-in cabinetry, offering a peaceful place to relax and enjoy the views. An elegant dining room with crown and picture frame moldings flows easily into the great room. The beautifully updated kitchen features quartz countertops, a subway tile backsplash, stainless steel appliances updated in 2022, including a gas cooktop and warming drawer, a generous pantry, and a sunny breakfast area. The spacious first-floor primary suite is a lovely retreat, with hardwood floors and a wall of windows overlooking the wooded privacy beyond. The updated primary bath features a beautiful tiled shower, double vanities with gorgeous new countertops, and a large walk-in closet. Upstairs, a cozy loft provides the perfect spot for a home office or reading nook. Two additional bedrooms share an updated Jack-and-Jill bath, offering comfortable accommodations for family and guests. Outdoor living is equally inviting, with a private, brick-walled courtyard patio creating a peaceful setting for morning coffee, birdwatching, or evening cocktails. An oversized 2½-car garage provides wonderful additional storage. With its beautiful setting, thoughtful updates, and outstanding proximity to Two Rivers Country Club, this lovely villa offers a wonderful opportunity to enjoy the Governor’s Land lifestyle!

1415 Katherine Shaye Lane, James City Co Greater Route 5

2333 W Island Road, James City Co Greater Route 5
$850,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3.1 Baths ⋅ 10660174 MLS
Motivated Sellers are offering their home at an exceptional value in Governors Land! Ideal combination of space, privacy & value, this thoughtfully updated, move-in-ready, 4 bedroom, 3.5-bath home sits on 0.87 private acres and offers 4,813 square feet of finished living space! With a 1ST FLOOR PRIMARY SUITE, 3 additional en-suite bedrooms upstairs, PLUS a spacious bonus room/5th bedroom, and an abundant conditioned flex space, the floor plan provides that rare flexibility to comfortably accommodate family, guests, work-from-home needs, hobbies or future customization. A welcoming Southern-style front porch opens to light-filled interiors with fresh paint, and beautiful millwork. The spacious kitchen is ideal for entertaining, featuring an oversized island, a casual dining area, and an easy flow into the sunroom. A private study with floor-to-ceiling built-ins and a formal dining room provide additional first-floor versatility. The first-floor primary suite offers a peaceful retreat with a serene view and a newly remodeled walk-in closet. Outside, enjoy a wooded and private setting from the rear deck with sunshade, with glimpses of the golf course and seasonal views of the James River. The nearly-acre, flat homesite provides plenty of room to enjoy the outdoors. Peace of mind with recent improvements such as a NEW ROOF, NEW CARPET, NEW DORMER WINDOWS, ENCAPSULATED CRAWL SPACE, NEW ATTIC INSULATION, fresh interior paint and improved professional landscaping! Enjoy the country club lifestyle with access to golf, tennis, swimming, marina, and riverfront dining. Convenient to Colonial Williamsburg, shopping, and area amenities. At only $176 a square foot, add this one on your list to see!

2333 W Island Road, James City Co Greater Route 5

Start Your Search

Some listings may be duplicated in the search results due to the co-mingling of listings from more than one multiple listing service. Should there be different listing information between the duplicated listings; user is advised to verify the accuracy of the listing information before making any financial decisions.

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!