Kingsmill Real Estate

Kingsmill Homes for Sale

Kingsmill is a stretch of James City County where about a quarter of the listings look out at water, a view from the house rather than frontage under it. The rest sit back from it, and the property here runs from houses on their own lots to condos and townhomes, so the search is less about one type of home than about which of them fits the way you want to spend a Saturday. Prices cluster in a broad middle band, and the housing stock has some age on it, which shapes what you inspect more than what you pay. David Tortolini Realty Group works this market closely and knows how these pockets differ from one another.

< Search all Homes for Sale in James City County, VA

Be the First to Know About New Kingsmill Homes

Stay ahead with real-time updates — no searching required.

See Homes Before Everyone Else

Kingsmill Real Estate Map Search

Kingsmill at a Glance

County
James City County County
ZIP codes in these listings
23185
Typical asking price
$629,500 (median of 34 homes, excluding 1 land and other non-dwelling listings)
Typical sold price
$667,000, middle half $500,000-$825,000 (median of 113 sales, past 12 months)
Typical home
2,523 sq ft (n=34) · 3 bed / 3 bath (medians, n=34)
Months of supply
3.7 (leaning to sellers)
Sold-to-list
100% of asking (median per home sale, n=113)
Data current as of
October 2026

How the Kingsmill market is moving

Start with the supply picture, which leans toward sellers. That is a ratio of what is listed against how quickly homes have been selling, and the useful thing it tells you is which direction this market tilts, nothing more precise than that. On deals that have already closed, sellers got at or above what they asked. Keep that in mind as context for the numbers you see on listing sheets. If your range is $500,000 to $1 million, know that this band makes up a bigger share of sales than it does of listings, so be ready to look at homes promptly and have your financing lined up before you start touring. Houses make up more than half of what is for sale, so if you want a condo or townhome, build that filter into your search from the start.

What your money buys in Kingsmill

A three-bedroom, the most common layout sold here, runs around $585,000. The largest single group of closed sales landed between $500,000 and $1 million, which is a fair guide to where the bulk of this market prices out. The typical home dates to 1986, with most falling between 1981 and 1990. That is a known set of things that come due: the roof, the furnace and air handler, the windows. A house at that age can show beautifully and still be due for one of them, so ask for dates on each before you decide what the home is worth to you. As for what is listed right now, more than half of it is houses, about a quarter condos, and about a fifth townhomes. Buy a house here and the yard, the roof and the mechanical systems are yours to run on your own schedule.

Views in Kingsmill listings

Listings here are commonly described by what the house looks out at, and two of those descriptions come up again and again: about half look out at woods, and about half look out at the golf course. Water views show up on about a fifth, and a river view on roughly one in ten. Worth keeping straight in your head is that a view is what you see, not what you own, so a water view and water frontage are two different listings. If a particular outlook is what you want, say so early and have it written into the search, because it is one of the few things you cannot change later.

Named communities within Kingsmill

A handful of names come up often enough in the listings to be worth knowing. Fairfax Woods accounts for about one in ten, and Whittakers Mill, Archers Mead, Harrops Glen and Padgetts Ordinary each account for about one in ten as well. Together those five names cover roughly half of what is listed here. The other half sits in smaller communities whose names you would never think to type into a search box. That is the practical catch with shopping Kingsmill by community name: you would miss most of the market doing it. Filter instead on price band, property class, and whether the home has the frontage or outlook you want, then look at which community each result lands in afterward.

What to verify before you commit

  • Mandatory club or social membership requirements tied to home purchase.
  • HOA and association assessments, dues, and reserve funding.
  • Flood zone status and insurance for properties near the James River.
  • Private road maintenance and gated community access obligations.
  • Architectural review and renovation approval requirements within Kingsmill.

Working with David Tortolini Realty Group

Two things on this page trip people up here. One is how closely sales run to the asking price, which changes how you read a listing sheet. The other is the association and membership side of owning in Kingsmill, along with flood zone and insurance questions on anything near the James River. David Tortolini Realty Group handles those conversations regularly and can take them apart with you on a specific address. If you want, send over the one or two listings you keep coming back to and we will go through the association documents and the river-proximity questions on each before you write anything.

Newest Homes for Sale in Kingsmill, James City County, VA

Start Your Search

Some listings may be duplicated in the search results due to the co-mingling of listings from more than one multiple listing service. Should there be different listing information between the duplicated listings; user is advised to verify the accuracy of the listing information before making any financial decisions.

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!